About

The Squeee banner with lots of pictures of things I enjoy

Categories

Currently Reading

From the Past

Films on the to-do list

  • Black Widow
  • Chimes at Midnight
  • Den blomstertid nu kommer (backed!)
  • Jojo Rabbit
  • The Killing of a Sacred Deer
  • Last Christmas
  • MIB: International
  • Remember Sunday
  • Shazam! 2
  • Spy Guys
  • Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
  • Wonder Woman: 1984

Jane by April Lindner (2010)

Book review: Jane by April Lindner (Poppy, 2010)

janeaprillindnerForced to drop out of an esteemed East Coast college after the sudden death of her parents, Jane Moore takes a nanny job at Thornfield Park, the estate of Nico Rathburn, a world-famous rock star on the brink of a huge comeback. Practical and independent, Jane reluctantly becomes entranced by her magnetic and brooding employer and finds herself in the midst of a forbidden romance.

But there’s a mystery at Thornfield, and Jane’s much-envied relationship with Nico is soon tested by an agonizing revelation from his past. Torn between her feelings for Nico and his fateful secret, Jane must decide: Does being true to herself mean giving up on true love?

An irresistible romance interwoven with a darkly engrossing mystery, this contemporary retelling of the beloved classic Jane Eyre promises to enchant a new generation of readers.

I got this book almost as soon as it was available, but it took me until very recently to actually read it. As I was trying to write my own modern take on Jane Eyre, I didn’t want to be influenced by someone else with essentially the same idea. Well, ten days into NaNoWriMo and I was stuck for ideas and just felt as if I was paraphrasing Charlotte Brontë in a slightly more modern setting. Who has house parties nowadays anyway? So I put the project on the shelf and eventually started reading April Lindner’s book.

Most of the bits I’ve read about it online have been positive. A lot of people really like this book, and it’s not without reason. The blurb from the left sleeve of the book (above) tells most of the story. Of course, based on Jane Eyre, we know the modern day Rochester is going to have skeletons in the closet – or rather, a mad wife in the attic – and that modern day Jane is going to be very hurt by this, so no real surprise there. By the way, I’m writing this assuming you, dear Reader, is fully familiar with Jane Eyre and what happens, so nothing in this review will truly spoil the story for you. After all, Jane is very faithful to the original.

While the story has moved to the US, Jane Moore is a nanny and Nico Rathburn is a rock star, all the little bits around this have changed and are still very recognisable. (Several characters even have their first or last names intact.) Jane Eyre is a timeless story, so why shouldn’t it translate very well? Having Rochester as a rock star made some elements come together beautifully: the house party is instead the band rehearsing, gold digger Blanche (here: Bianca) Ingram is a famous photographer of the stars, and so on.

Several scenes from the original are included – to my delight, this includes the “and a little depressed” scene – and the dialogue is recognisable too, if adapted and modernised. There is no gipsy woman, but instead, a partner of one of the band members is good at reading Tarot cards. Here, I applaud April Lindner. She actually seems to know what she’s talking about, which (sadly) most people who include Tarot cards in their books or films don’t. (The Gift even went as far as having Cate Blanchett tell the future using Zener cards, which was so ridiculous it spoiled the whole movie.)

Another thing April Lindner has done very well is the Morton part of the book. The St John siblings are never her cousins, but they become very good friends. River St John is just as creepy as St John Rivers and he doesn’t want Jane to learn Hindustani and become a missionary in India with him, but rather study French and take her to Haiti to help rebuilding the country after the earthquake. And so on. It’s perfectly adapted to modern day!

The characters are also very similar, although perhaps not 100% their predecessors. Nico Rathburn is definitely Nico Rathburn and not Edward Fairfax Rochester. There are similarities between the two, certainly, but they’re not identical. Which I suppose is just as well. They are two different novels.

One thing that is a distinct difference is the attitude of the times. Pre-marital sex isn’t a problem nowadays, so Lindner lets her protagonists jump into bed before there’s even been a proposal. Speaking of which, the second proposal made me smile and think “you go, girl!” at the author. What a great update of “Reader, I married him”!

As a version of Jane Eyre, this is very enjoyable. Very well-written and very satisfying from the perspective of someone who loves the original. This is an excellent tribute, and just a shame it doesn’t come with a soundtrack! The only negative is the way the pages have been cut – they’re all uneven on the longer side, as if they’ve not gone through the cutting machine properly, and it makes it tricky to turn pages, as I often got two pages at a time instead of just one. But who really cares when you’re engrossed in a great story?

5 out of 5 guitar solos.

Traxy Thornfield

A Swedish introvert residing in Robin Hood Country (Nottingham, UK) with a husband and two cats. She's an eager participant in tabletop and play-by-post roleplaying, woodworking, photography and European travel. Will get a novel out one of these days, if she doesn't get too distracted along the way.

7 thoughts on “Jane by April Lindner (2010)

  1. I believe you’re referring to “deckled” edges. The publisher is trying to be arty. Makes for a good-looking book but not always the easiest for page-turning.

  2. Really? What a silly idea! Instead of looking arty, it just looks out of place and that the book hasn’t been finished properly. Thanks for clarifying! 🙂

  3. Yeah – I’m a designer and, the deckled look can be used to good effect but more often than not, it’s misused, over-used, and out of place which is a shame!

  4. See… I don’t know if I could handle this. I enjoy a good revisit of a famous plot, but it has to be subtle enough for me to really enjoy it. I like to feel clever when I spot the similarities, rather than feel like I’m being bashed over the head with them.

    But maybe it’s more subtle than it seems.

    My favourite re-visit is Bridget Jones’ Diary. It’s a wonderful redo of Pride And Prejudice, even though pretty much every element has been changed.

    I’d happily read a modern retelling of Jane Eyre, but I don’t think I want to try this one. Maybe when you write yours!

  5. It’s not really subtle, no. It’s quite clearly a modern re-telling of Jane Eyre, because you can recognise the characters and the plot so easily. Like you say, Bridget Jones is more subtle.

    Maybe because P&P deals with an easier plot. “They hate each other because one is too proud and one is prejudied and then they end up falling in love” is fairly easy to translate into anything because it’s so universal. Bit more difficult trying to get around “She has a crappy childhood, becomes a governess to a bastard child, falls in love with the master of the house who has a mad wife in the attic”, and so on.

    If I finish mine, it would be very much like Jane Eyre but 180 years later. While Lindner made Rochester a rock star and placed Thornfield in America, I’ve kept it in Britain, and he’s a business man or something (bit hazy on that point). Oh, and I made Jane a Swedish au pair. 😀 Other than that, there would be no hesitation as to where the plot came from! But thank you, nonetheless! 🙂

  6. is there a movie for this book i really loved the book i really want it to be a movie if it nots someone should consider making it one

  7. It only came out about six months ago, so it’s a bit too quick to have been snatched up by a movie company just yet (as far as I know anyway). I agree, though, it would make a great movie! 🙂

Leave a Reply to olivia Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: